Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tim Miller's avatar

Fascinating! And makes a huge amount of sense. I think a really good story or novel can cause emotions as well as, or almost as well as, really good music. So words can do it too, but music is definitely an emotion-generator. Music definitely makes you want to move more than words ever could (though I suppose one might argue that words can make especially groups of people cooperate in the motion of violence).

Expand full comment
Byron B. Carrier's avatar

Great summary!

There are estimates of when humans first used fire and the wheel. I wonder when music began. Flutes date back some 30,000 years. How old is knocking rocks together for rhythm? How about sounds other than words? Dancing?

Some animals, like parrots, have a better sense of rhythm than some humans. The rhythm and language areas of the brain are larger for us and those animals. We're just beginning to decipher the language and songs of other animals.

Early birth, instead of the twelve months animals our size should have, leaves us vulnerable and dependent. Slings to carry babies and songs to soothe them may be among the earliest of what make us human.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts